The Performance of the Judiciary in Conflicts in Indigenous Lands in Bahia: A Study of the Possessory Actions against Indigenous Communities in Bahia, Brazil

  • Sara da Nova Côrtes Federal University of Bahia, Brazil
Keywords: law, judiciary, possessory actions, land conflicts, indigenous communities

Abstract

The maintenance of the phenomenon of “land injustice” was widely studied in its genesis in Brazil in a contradictory process. The action (or inaction) of justice resulted in disrespect for the communal traditions of the original peoples, consecrating private property as an absolute right. The purpose of this article is to understand how the Judiciary, after the Constitution (1988), has been active in conflicts involving indigenous lands. There are presumptions as stratagems of judicial ideology that confirm the argument of in dubio pro “owner.” It operates with the presumption of historical non-existence (of indigenous people) and clandestinity when indigenous people are considered as capitis diminutio – outside the law, even if they can be represented as subjects of law in the judicial space. The study was developed through a documentary research in 212 lawsuits with the indigenous peoples Pataxós and Tupinambás in the judicial proceedings (possessory actions, Sub-sections of Ilhéus, Federal Justice/Bahia). The discourse analysis procedure allowed us to dismantle the idea that the judiciary would be “the place where justice is done” or “the law applies,” at least where “the law is said” or where “conflicts are measured.” We affirm that this power is a space where in doubt it is decided in favor of “owners.”

Author Biography

Sara da Nova Côrtes, Federal University of Bahia, Brazil

PhD in Social Sciences from the Federal University of Bahia (2017). Assistant Level III Professor at the Federal University of Bahia and Coordinator of the Research and Extension Nucleus (NPE) of the FDUFBA Law School. Director of the Association of Rural Workers Advocates (2005-2009). Visiting professor at the State University of Bahia UNEB (2007-2010). 

References

Almeida, A. W. B. (2004, maio). Terras Tradicionalmente Ocupadas: processos de Territorialização, Movimentos Sociais e uso comum, Revista Brasileira de Estudos Urbanos e Regionais, 6 (01), pp. 9-32.

Carvalho, M. do R. (2009, Set/Dez.). O Monte Pascoal, os índios pataxó e a luta pelo seu reconhecimento étnico. Caderno CRH, 22 (57), pp. 507-521.

Gileno, C. H. (2007, Jan./Abr.). A legislação indígena: ambigüidades na formação do Estado-Nação no Brasil, CADERNO CRH, 20 (49), pp. 123-133.

Marcato, A. C. (2005). Procedimentos especiais. 11. ed. rev., ampl. e atual. de acordo com o novo Código Civil. São Paulo: Atlas.

Martins, J. de S. (1981). Os camponeses e a política no Brasil. Rio de Janeiro: Vozes.

Orlandi, Eni P. (2015). Análise de Discurso: princípios e procedimentos. 12ª Edição, Campinas: Pontes Editores.

Orlandi, Eni P. (2007). As formas do silêncio: no movimento dos sentidos, 6ª Ed. Campinas, SP: Editora da UNICAMP.

Published
2019-06-30